Reader Question – The book about the Hero that ditches her for her sister…

UPDATE!! WE’VE MADE A WHOLE LIST right here on this post, for our In Love With Her Sister’s Man” category!! 😀

Rekha is looking for this book! Oooooh what an angsty situation indeed (I’ve actually read a few like this, including “The Bronze Horseman” that ripped my heart out, but I’m pretty sure that’s not the one she’s looking for.

P.S. I DO have a category for this exact thing (well… mostly. 😉 “In Love With Her Sister’s Man” category, so it might be in there! This category is not huge yet, but it might be fun to build a list for it.

She asks:

I am looking for a book on kindle unlimited where the synopsis says:

that the h thought she had a fairy tale life and was in love with H. However she is disillusioned after H ditches her for her sister. h goes away heartbroken and returns few years later for her fathers funeral and the story continues from here.

h name is either Jessica or Jennifer and I think H’s name starts with C but not very sure of this.

I read the synopsis on kindle unlimited. Would be really lovely if you can locate this book for me.

Anyone have a guess? Let’s make a list!

Maryse: Right off the bat, a few that come to mind that are similar but probably not what she’s looking for:

• Something in the Way by Jessica Hawkins
• The Bronze Horseman by Paullina Simons
• Heat Wave by Karina Halle <— It’s actually her sister who dies in this one, and that’s why the H and h see each other again.

Leslie M: I’m probably way off as the details are fuzzy…but I thought The Gravity of Us by Brittainy Cherry involved a funeral & h’s sister.

Amy: Breaking Beauty: A Second Chance Romance by Stella Andrews

Christine: Sins of Sevin is another about falling in love with his fiancée sister. Don’t think it’s this one though.

JulieO: How about the Black Swan Affair?

Rekha: Thanks for all the suggestions. But unfortunately it’s none of these though breaking beauty comes close . I hope one of you is able to help me locate this book.

Lola: Is it Ruckus (Sinners of Saint Book 3) by LJ Shen?

Rekha: Sorry Lola it is not ruckus. I really hope some one will locate this book for me. Thanks all for your efforts

Rekha: Any more suggestions on this folks ? Am still looking forward to solving this one? Thanks

Jackie: Does the sister die?

Kadie: Home torn by Tijan Re-written and released as Home Tears.

Joy: Something in the Way series by Jessica Hawkins?

Lauren: Breaking Beauty: A Second Chance Romance by Stella Andrews. She comes back for her father’s funeral. Just read this last week. Pretty sure it’s the one you’re looking for.

Maryse: I added that one when Amy guessed it, and Rekha said none of these were the one yet. I’ll add your suggestion again though, just in case it was overlooked.

Rehka: It’s still not the one . But I have lived getting the list of books and have started reading some of them. Thanks all and still hope to solve the book I am looking for

Jessica: is It How We Fall by Melissa Toppen? This one the H hooks up with a friend not a sister and they reunite for a friends funeral. It sounds kind of angsty-esque? lol

Jessica: One more I thought of! But it might not be what you’re looking for. Out from Under You (Smart Girls Finish First Book 1), by Sophie Swift. 😀

➔➔➔  Browse more reader questions (solved & unsolved) here. 😀 Maybe you’ll find a solved one to read or have a guess for us for one that’s still unsolved.

Have a reader question for us to solve? Send it to me here.